This is the most common fencing question I get, and the honest answer is that close board fencing is almost always the better long-term choice for a permanent boundary fence in Surrey. But panel fencing has its place. Here is a clear comparison.
Close Board Fencing
Close board fencing, also called featherboard or feather-edge fencing, uses overlapping tapered boards nailed vertically to horizontal rails, with the posts and rails providing the structural frame. When installed with concrete posts and gravel boards, it is the most durable residential fencing you can buy.
Why concrete posts? Wooden posts rot at ground level, typically within 8–12 years. Concrete posts never rot. The difference in longevity is significant, a well-installed close board fence with concrete posts and gravel boards should last 20–25 years without major work.
Gravel boards are the bottom horizontal board at ground level. They protect the feather-edge boards from ground contact and moisture. When they rot (every 5–10 years), you replace the gravel board, not the whole fence.
Panel Fencing
Panel fencing uses pre-made panels that slot or clip between posts. It is faster to install and therefore cheaper, typical costs are £40–£80 per metre lower than close board. The downside is longevity. Panel fencing typically lasts 8–12 years, and individual panels are not as structurally robust as a properly built close board fence.
Panel fencing is a good choice when budget is the primary concern or when a fence needs replacing quickly (storm damage, for example) rather than to a high permanent standard.
Cost Comparison
- Close board (installed): £90–£140 per metre
- Panel fencing (installed): £55–£90 per metre
Which Should You Choose?
If you want a fence that lasts and you are not planning to move in the next few years: close board. If budget is tight or you need a temporary fix: panel. If you are selling and just need the garden to look presentable: panel.
Learn more about our close board fencing installation or get a free quote.